
“That Ain’t What My Bible Say”: Bishop Sheard, ‘Jesus Only’ and the Fight Over God’s Name
The Bishop, the Name and the Ocean: what COGIC’s presiding bishop taught the 118th Holy Convocation about baptism, God’s name and why some young people are leaving
“That Ain’t What My Bible Say”: Bishop Sheard, ‘Jesus Only’ and the Fight Over God’s Name
By Latisha Sky | Prodigal Breaking News | prodigalbreakingnews.com
November 6, 2026
At the 118th Holy Convocation of the Church of God in Christ in St. Louis, Presiding Bishop J. Drew Sheard used his Thursday "Morning Manna" teaching to take on a question that has divided Black Pentecostal churches for more than a century: in whose name should believers be baptized? He argued that Peter's call to be baptized "in the name of Jesus" in Acts 2:38 was aimed at a specific audience, compared God's names to his own three names, and rejected the "Jesus only" view: "that ain't what my Bible say." He also said the church is losing "some of our young people" because it hasn't taught them its doctrine. National research on why people leave religion tells a more complicated story.
[CONFIRMED] Presiding Bishop J. Drew Sheard, leader of the Church of God in Christ, the largest predominantly Black Pentecostal denomination in the United States, taught the "Morning Manna" session of the church's 118th Holy Convocation in St. Louis on Thursday, Nov. 5. The session was livestreamed. Sheard presented it as a Bible lesson, with scripture read aloud by Dr. Dorinda Clark-Cole, his sister-in-law, the way he runs the Bible class he teaches at his church.
He opened by noting that he usually keeps that class off the air. "I do it for in-person Bible class only," he said, "so that the critics can't pick apart what I'm saying." This lesson, he said, "is going to be a little different."
[CONFIRMED] The name in Acts 2:38. Sheard's text was the Great Commission in Matthew 28, where Jesus tells his followers to baptize "in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost." He then turned to Acts 2:38, the verse at the center of the "Jesus name" baptism tradition, where Peter tells the crowd to "be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ."
"Peter said that you're to be baptized in the name of Jesus," Sheard said. "But you ain't got that right. Because you don't understand who Peter was talking to." Peter's audience, he argued, was Israelites who had rejected Jesus as the Messiah. "The Jews already believe in God. They already believe in the Holy Spirit," he said. "Now you got to get Jesus in your baptismal formula."
Sheard did not say that baptisms performed in Jesus' name are invalid. His target was how believers read Peter's words.
[CONFIRMED] Three names. Then he offered an illustration. "What is God's name? Jesus. I agree," he said. "But he got some other name. My name is Drew. But my other name is John. And then I got another name. Sheard. And if you call any one of those three names, I'm going to look around."
Minutes later, he turned to the baptism of Jesus in Matthew 3, where the Spirit descends like a dove and a voice from heaven says, "This is my beloved Son." "Now you say that is Jesus only," Sheard said. "But that ain't what my Bible say."
[CONFIRMED] The fault line he stepped into. Sheard was speaking into one of the oldest divides in American Pentecostalism. COGIC's statement of faith says there is "only One God, eternally existent in three persons: God the Father, God the Son and, God the Holy Spirit." Oneness, or Apostolic, churches, including the Pentecostal Assemblies of the World and the Church of Our Lord Jesus Christ, teach that Father, Son and Holy Spirit are not three persons but ways the one God has revealed himself, fully present in Jesus, and that baptism should be "in the name of Jesus." That movement broke away in 1913–1916. The two families of churches share worship styles, songs and, often, relatives.
[ANALYSIS] Where his argument holds, and where it's tested. Sheard's reading fits Acts 2, where Peter addresses "all the house of Israel." It is harder to apply to the rest of Acts. Samaritans (Acts 8:16) and the Gentile household of Cornelius (Acts 10:48) were also baptized in the name of Jesus. In Acts 19, disciples at Ephesus who said they had "not so much as heard whether there be any Holy Ghost" were baptized "in the name of the Lord Jesus." That is a different audience from the one Sheard described.
His names illustration also cuts in two directions. One man with three names is the picture Oneness teachers themselves use, so a sermon arguing for distinction among Father, Son and Spirit illustrated it with an image of one person. Sheard's own words make clear he rejects "Jesus only." But Oneness believers hearing the sermon can fairly say he agreed with them twice: that God's name is Jesus, and that Acts describes a "baptismal formula" in Jesus' name.
History can show what Christians taught and when. The earliest church manuals after the New Testament, the Didache and Justin Martyr's writings in the second century, use the threefold wording. The Didache also speaks of those "baptized into the name of the Lord." Doctrines about the Trinity developed over centuries; they were not invented at a single council. What history cannot settle is which account of God is true. That is a question of faith.
[CONFIRMED] "Some of our young people." Sheard tied the sermon to a pastoral worry. "The reason why we losing some of our young people is because we haven't put the doctrine of our church in them," he said. "Nobody enjoys shouting more than I do. But you got to stop shouting and teach the people what they shouting about." Those young people, he said, are "going to other denominations that don't believe what we believe," drawn by "a good feel-good experience," but "they don't know what they believe."
He described a member who had begun attending another ministry. "I don't have no problem with you going to another church," he recalled telling the member, but "you can't be a member of both our churches." He urged members to use a doctrinal "checklist" before joining another church, and, to laughter, said that if "you feel the Lord is leading you then you may go."
[CONFIRMED] What the research says. National surveys back part of Sheard's diagnosis and complicate the rest. They measure Americans broadly; we found no study of COGIC members specifically.
- Belief matters for staying. In Pew Research Center's 2025 study of why people leave or keep their childhood religion, 64% of those who stayed said they believe its teachings, the top reason given.
- But among those who left, the top reason was that they stopped believing the teachings (46%), ahead of drifting away (38%) or finding religion unimportant (38%). Many also cited the church's stances on social and political issues (34%) or scandals involving clergy (32%). PRRI's 2023 study found the same top reason, at 56%.
- Most young people who leave don't switch churches. Among Americans under 30 raised in a religion, Pew found 10% now belong to a different religion, while 35% belong to none.
- Leaving church is not leaving God. Among Black Americans with no religious affiliation, 83% say they believe in God, according to Pew.
That leaves an open question for any church: if many who leave already know the teachings and no longer find them credible, will more teaching bring them back?
[COMMENTARY] What Prodigal sees. Sheard's sermon turned on a name: which name God answers to, which name belongs in the water. Christianity's own teachers have long said that God is greater than any name for God. Trinitarian theologians call their doctrine a mystery; mystics such as Meister Eckhart spoke of a ground deeper than every word. Prodigal's view, offered as a perspective and not a verdict, is that much of this fight assumes a self that stands apart from God and must be joined to God by the right word. Think of a wave arguing over which name will save it, when it was never anything but ocean.
The debate is over which name saves the wave. The older question is whether the ocean was ever lost.
Notice the pattern. Interrupt it.
— Latisha Sky, Prodigal Breaking News
Sources: "Bishop J. Drew Sheard | Morning Manna | 118th Holy Convocation" (broadcast, Nov. 5, 2026; quotations verified against the audio); Church of God in Christ, Statement of Faith (cogic.org); Pew Research Center, "Why Do Some Americans Leave Their Religion…" (Dec. 15, 2025); Pew Research Center, Black Americans and religion key facts (Dec. 2025); PRRI, "Unveiling the Exodus" (July 2023); St. Louis Public Radio and St. Louis American on the Holy Convocation's 2026–2028 return to St. Louis; Acts 2, 8, 10, 19; Matthew 3, 28 (KJV); the Didache, ch. 7 and 9; Justin Martyr, First Apology 61.
Image: AI-generated illustration, not a photograph.
Ask Prodigal about this story
Got a question about what you just read? Ask, and get an answer drawn from this story.
5 free questions left today. Answers come only from this story and can be imperfect.
Want unlimited conversations? Try Prodigal AI