POWER WATCH
Back to Home
A Judge Ruled Against His Authority. Again.
Breaking News

A Judge Ruled Against His Authority. Again.

For the second time in a year, a federal judge found Bill Essayli is unlawfully running the country's largest federal prosecutor's office. The order is on hold while the government decides whether to appeal.

A Judge Ruled Against His Authority. Again.

By Grant Keller | Prodigal Breaking News | prodigalbreakingnews.com

October 28, 2026

Bill EssayliU.S. AttorneyLos AngelesAppointmentsSenate ConfirmationRule of Law

On Tuesday, U.S. District Judge Michael Seabright ruled that Bill Essayli is "unlawfully" serving as the "de facto" U.S. attorney in Los Angeles, and disqualified him from supervising two criminal prosecutions. It is Seabright's second ruling against Essayli's appointment. The order isn't in effect yet: the government has five business days to ask for a stay. Essayli says the question "will be decided by the Supreme Court."

By Grant Keller | Prodigal Breaking News | prodigalbreakingnews.com

What the judge ruled

Judge Michael Seabright found that Bill Essayli, whose current title is first assistant U.S. attorney, is "unlawfully" serving as the "de facto" U.S. attorney for the Central District of California. He disqualified Essayli from taking part in or supervising two prosecutions: Jaime Hector Ramirez, charged as a felon in possession of a firearm, and Tu Anh Tran, charged with possessing stolen interstate shipments. Seabright declined to dismiss either indictment.

The order doesn't take effect right away. Seabright gave the government five business days to seek a stay pending appeal. Essayli said his office "respectfully" disagrees, that the question "will be decided by the Supreme Court," and that he looks forward to serving "until then."

How he got here

Essayli, a former California assemblyman, was sworn in as interim head of the office in April 2025. When his temporary term ran out, the administration kept him in charge under different titles. In October 2025, Seabright ruled he was not lawfully serving as acting U.S. attorney but let him keep running the office as first assistant.

Since then, appeals courts have ruled that two other Trump-picked prosecutors, Sigal Chattah in Nevada and John Sarcone in Albany, were unlawfully appointed through similar title changes. Seabright's new ruling says the "first assistant" label doesn't fix the problem.

The Central District covers Los Angeles and six other counties, nearly 20 million people. Essayli's office says it is the largest federal judicial district in the country.

The pattern

The Constitution says top federal prosecutors are nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate. Interim appointments have limits for a reason. When the limit runs out and the same person stays in charge under a new title, the rule hasn't been followed. It's been renamed. Courts keep saying so. The administration keeps taking it to the next court. Meanwhile, the people being prosecuted in that district are left asking who has the authority to charge them.

Image: AI-generated editorial illustration. It does not show the actual people, places or events in this story.

Notice the pattern. Interrupt it.


Sources: CBS Los Angeles; LAist; The Week; AP (via Just Security).

Ask Prodigal about this story

Got a question about what you just read? Ask, and get an answer drawn from this story.

5 free questions left today. Answers come only from this story and can be imperfect.

Want unlimited conversations? Try Prodigal AI

Share this story