POWER WATCH
Back to Home
The Illusion of Becoming
Breaking News

The Illusion of Becoming

Prodigal: The Podcast, Episode 52. What if the person you've been trying to become was never missing?

The Illusion of Becoming

By Don Jackson | Prodigal Breaking News | prodigalbreakingnews.com

November 18, 2026

Religion & PowerSpiritualityNondualityLeaving ChurchProdigal Original
Listen to the full episode

Church told a lot of us we weren't enough yet, and much of the spiritual world sold us the same message in softer language. On Prodigal: The Podcast Episode 52, Don Jackson and Daysha Voss take on the illusion of becoming, then put it to two tests: does it change how you live, and does it change how we treat each other? Plus Daysha's meditation, "Nothing to Become."

Image: Prodigal: The Podcast Episode 52 artwork.

Here's a question I asked on the show this week. Answer it honestly, just to yourself.

You're stranded on a desert island, and you get to pick one person to be stuck there with you. Option one is the smartest spiritual mind you've ever met. They know every scripture, every teacher, every theory about God and consciousness, and they can explain all of it. And they're miserable. Option two is somebody who has never read a page of philosophy and doesn't care to. But they're at peace. They're kind. They're easy to be around. A happy camper.

You took the happy camper. So did I. And when that exact question was put to two men who have spent their whole lives on this subject, a philosopher and a teacher of nonduality, they both took the happy camper too. One of them said: any day of the week, twice on Sunday.

If the people who know the most pick the person who knows the least, then what you know was never the point. And maybe what you've been chasing wasn't either.

The recipes didn't work

Every one of us wants to be happy. Even the person who chooses sacrifice is choosing it because somewhere inside it there's a peace they're after. Wanting it isn't the problem. The problem is where we look.

We were handed recipes. From our parents, from society, from the church. Get the degree. Get the spouse. Get the house. Get saved. Get anointed. Get the title. And for a lot of us, the recipes just didn't work. Not because we followed them wrong, but because we were looking for peace where it can't be found: in the things that come and go. Anything that can show up can also leave. The job. The relationship. The feeling you had at the altar call.

So if peace can't be found in what comes and goes, there's only one place left to look: the one who watched it all come and go. Not the you on paper. The you that's aware. The one that's been here for every chapter.

Same climb, softer shoes

This is where a lot of us who left get caught.

The church told us we weren't enough yet. Not holy enough. Not saved enough. Not anointed enough. Keep coming back. Keep giving. Keep becoming. So we left the building. And then the spiritual world sold us the same message in softer language. Not awake enough. Not enlightened enough. Sign up for the next retreat.

That's the illusion of becoming. We climb down the church ladder and start up a spiritual one. Same climb, softer shoes.

The teacher in that conversation put it in a way that stopped me cold: Nobody is enlightened. Nothing limited is enlightened. Only consciousness is enlightened, and you, and I, and everybody else, are that consciousness.

There's no finish line, because there's no runner. The seeker, the one trying to get there, is the obstacle. The searching is what keeps you from noticing what's already here.

And no, that doesn't mean you quit and sit on the couch. You can't force yourself to stop searching. That's just seeking with extra steps. The teaching is clear: the stopping can't be forced. It has to come naturally.

How does it come naturally? Picture the stars before sunrise. At night they're the brightest things in the sky. Those are the things we want: money, approval, being somebody. Then dawn starts to come, and the stars fade. Not because anybody defeated them. Not because they got weaker. Because a much bigger light is coming up. You don't beat desire. You outgrow it. The old things still shine. They just stop being the only light you can see.

Or think about a teenager's party. When the parents leave for the weekend, what do the kids need to throw a party? Nothing. They just need the parents gone. You don't have to add happiness to your life, or build it, or buy it, or earn it. You need the worry to leave the house: the constant worry of a self that believes it's on its own. Get that out, and the rest falls into place.

Happiness isn't added. It's uncovered.

Test one: does it change how you live?

It's easy to say all of that. The question is whether it changes anything on a Tuesday.

The philosopher in that conversation answered honestly, and I respect him for it. He has two doctorates. He has spent his career arguing that consciousness is the foundation of reality. And he admitted that years in, already known for it, he still carried tremendous anxiety, a sense of impending doom. The idea was in his head. It didn't sink in.

A lot of us think that if we can just get the right understanding, the pain will stop. Here was a man who understood it better than almost anyone, and his body hadn't gotten the memo.

Slowly, over years, it began to sink in. And the way he described the change is something I want everyone reading this to hear. The desire to be happy didn't go away. What went away was the narrative: I must make myself happy. That job. That project. Gone. And here's the paradox: the moment you give up trying to make yourself happy at any cost, you start to become happy. He was careful about the word. He called it a kind of contentment. Things are fine.

If you've ever lived with anxiety, you know "things are fine" is everything.

He named two roads to it. Either you surrender after failure, because you tried every recipe and they all broke. Or, quietly, over time, making yourself happy simply stops being the goal. The first road is the Prodigal story. You leave because the old recipe failed.

How can someone understand all this and still suffer? His answer: we are all of many minds, and those minds don't always agree. You can be completely convinced in your reasoning and still be terrified in your gut. Your head is running the new idea while your emotional life runs the old program.

It works the other way too. The two of them were asked about a neighbor, a materialist who doesn't believe any of this, who thinks it's all just matter, and who lives in a near-constant state of delight, standing by the water and enjoying his life. What's he missing? Maybe nothing. His head says matter, but his heart lives in a sense of unity. He's settled. He's at peace.

The conclusion they both came to is the sentence I'd put over the door of every church I grew up in:

How we live is much more important than how we think.

So many of our institutions measure people by what they believe: the right doctrine, the right baptism, the right name. Meanwhile, the kindest person you know might not believe any of it. The happy camper wins the island. That's the guard against spiritual superiority. If you ever catch yourself looking down on someone because they haven't "woken up" yet, you just failed the test.

For those of us who need the head to come first, the philosopher had a line I can't stop thinking about: the mind is the bouncer of the heart. If your mind can't find a reason to open the door, the heart never gets in. If you grew up being told your feelings were the flesh, your questions were rebellion and your doubts were the devil, your mind is standing at that door with its arms crossed. Sometimes you need the reasoning first, just to give yourself permission to feel what you already know.

So thinking isn't the enemy. There's an old picture from India: it's the wind that brings the clouds in front of the sun, and it's the wind that chases them away. Thinking can cloud it. Thinking can clear it.

And meditation isn't a contest. The philosopher admitted he wasn't born with the skill. He bought one of those headbands that reads your brain waves, stormy when you're doing it wrong, a gentle breeze when you're doing it right, and he said he was terrible at it and was going to throw it away. The teaching on this is clear: if meditation starts with a me trying to reach a goal, all it does is make the me stronger. You can't fail at being what you already are. The scoreboard was the problem.

What about the stuff that doesn't go away? The teaching has a word for it: leftovers. A parking ticket still annoys you. Taxes still annoy you. Those are old habits, reflexes. But the big thing underneath, the sense of impending doom, once it's been seen through, has lost its foundation. The con artist has been found out. He may keep running the old tricks out of habit, but you've seen how the trick works.

So, test one. Does it change how you live? Yes. Not overnight, and not by believing harder, but by noticing more. The evidence isn't how well you can explain it. It's whether you're kinder, more honest and more present than you were.

Test two: does it change how we treat each other?

Here's where I have to be careful, because everything above could sound like: find your inner peace, close your eyes, feel fine.

This same week we reported on a billion-dollar deportation airline, and on more than 150 Afghans waiting to find out whether the next flight leaves in December. You can't meditate that away, and you shouldn't try.

The philosopher said it honestly. The more aware he became of the suffering out there, every day, every single second, the more it felt like the absolute opposite of happiness. Part of him wanted to run, close the door, lock it and throw away the key. He called it exposure exhaustion. Fifteen years ago he wasn't sensitive to it. Now he is. And he said: I do resist. I get angry at what we are doing in the world to each other.

Spirituality has a bad habit of rushing to the peaceful part. Seeing more doesn't always feel better at first. Sometimes it feels worse.

The teacher's answer is one I had to sit with. Psychological suffering, even the suffering that comes with empathy, traces back to one thing: the belief that you're a separate self carrying it all by yourself. And the instruction is not to push it away. If you resist it, it's awful. If you see it for what it is, it's like a wave moving through your body. Feelings, as he teaches it, are sensations we push against. They push one way, we push the other. Stop pushing, let it unfold all the way, and the body knows how to release itself.

Think about a wild rabbit in the grass. It hears a noise and every muscle tenses. The next moment, it lets go and goes back to eating. We hear the noise and stay tense for twenty years. Some of us are carrying a noise our grandparents heard. The rabbit is telling you the body already knows the way back.

Then he told a story. At a gathering in Canada, a deeply troubled woman described her pain. She said it was like a knife. In that moment, he said, it felt as if something jumped onto him: an intense fear unlike anything he had felt in his life. He didn't run from it and he didn't drown in it. He stayed in the part of himself that wasn't shaken, and he asked her gently: Is it that bad, the knife? She started crying, and she was relieved.

He didn't fix her. He felt it all the way through, with love, from the place in him that wasn't afraid, and as it moved through him, something happened in her. That's the difference between empathy that drowns you and empathy that frees somebody.

And for the whole world? The teacher was realistic: we cannot solve the world. All we can do is sing our own song, and take care, the best we can, of the stranger we meet. The friend. The partner. The children.

Some people will hear that as convenient. Take care of your own and let the rest burn. I don't hear it as a way out. I hear it as a way in. Because the question is: who's the stranger?

The stranger is a name on a flight list in Louisiana, waiting to find out if the plane leaves in December.

The stranger is the researcher whose grant got searched for the wrong words.

The stranger is sitting in a detention center owned by a company that somebody's retirement fund is invested in. This week, the Catholic bishops voted to stop investing in private prisons and detention facilities. Whatever you think about the bishops, on that one they followed their own money.

If we are one reality, there's no such thing as somebody else's child on that plane. The stranger we meet now includes the ones we read about, the ones we vote about, the ones our money touches. Oneness doesn't let you look away. And it doesn't ask you to drown. Feel it all the way through. Don't lock the door and throw away the key. Let it move through you. Then move.

That's the second test. If your awakening makes you colder to the stranger, it isn't awakening. It's just a nicer-looking wall.

The lab of life: practices for this week

None of these needs a religion, a guru or a membership.

  1. Take it to the lab of life. Once a day, in one ordinary moment, live as if the plain, everyday awareness you have right now is the awareness of the whole universe. Then meet one person that way, with no distance, as if you're meeting yourself. Watch what happens. The prediction is simple: more harmony, inside and around you. Hold it with an open hand. On the level of the mind you can never be completely certain, so keep asking. Your daily life becomes the lab.
  2. Keep the wish. Drop the job. Notice when you're working to manufacture happiness. Let the project go and keep the wish.
  3. Let one feeling run all the way through. When something hits you, find where it sits in your body, your chest, your stomach, your throat, and stop pushing back. Let it move like the rabbit's fear moves.
  4. Meet people with the walls down. A real encounter doesn't need agreement. It needs whatever is between you not to be held so tight.
  5. Count small talk. "Lovely weather, isn't it?" is a handshake. Two strangers showing each other they're not a threat. There's common ground under it before anyone names it.
  6. Be honest with yourself first. Experience is true as experience. It's when we turn it into words that it can go wrong very easily.
  7. Follow your enthusiasm. There is no one-size-fits-all road. Action, love, study, silence: the path that actually lights you up is probably your door.
  8. If you're a thinker, think. Sincerely asking, Is this awareness real? Is it limited to this body? is already the practice. A thought that truly questions the belief that you're limited is the wind clearing the clouds.
  9. Throw away the scoreboard. A wandering mind in meditation isn't failure. There's no one there to fail.
  10. Name one stranger. Each day, bring to mind one person you'll never meet who is waiting on a decision someone else will make. Then ask what your song can do for them.

Nothing to become

Church told a lot of us we weren't enough yet. When we left, a lot of spirituality told us the same thing in softer language. Becoming enlightened can be just another way of becoming somebody.

So here's the question I'll leave with you: What if the last thing you have to surrender is the belief that you still need to arrive?

Stop making happiness your job. You don't have to build it. You have to let the worry leave the house. Then put it to the two tests. Are you living differently: kinder, more honest, more present? And are you treating the stranger differently, including the one on the flight list, including the one you'll never meet?

There's an old story from India about a king who dreamed he was a beggar. He woke up confused and asked his teacher: Am I a king who dreamed he was a beggar, or a beggar dreaming he's a king? The teacher said: You're neither. You're the one who was aware of both.

The stars don't lose their light at dawn. They just stop being the only light you can see.

Nothing to become. Only something to notice.

Notice the pattern. Interrupt it.


Listen: Prodigal: The Podcast, Episode 52, "The Illusion of Becoming," with Don Jackson and Daysha Voss, closing with Daysha's meditation, "Nothing to Become."

This week's news referenced: Religion News Service on the U.S. Catholic bishops' investment vote (Nov. 18, 2026) · Prodigal Breaking News on ICE's charter-flight contracts and the Afghan deportation flights · Prodigal Breaking News on the Supreme Court and the University of California research grants

Further reading: Don Jackson, Prodigal: Leaving Church and Finding God · Prodigal: The Podcast, Episode 49, "Who Is Doing the Searching?"

Ask Prodigal about this story

Got a question about what you just read? Ask, and get an answer drawn from this story.

5 free questions left today. Answers come only from this story and can be imperfect.

Want unlimited conversations? Try Prodigal AI

Share this story