POWER WATCH
Back to Home
Who Is Doing the Searching?
Breaking News

Who Is Doing the Searching?

Religion taught us to search for God. Maybe the search began with a mistake: the assumption that the one searching is separate from what they're looking for.

Who Is Doing the Searching?

By Don Jackson | Prodigal Breaking News | prodigalbreakingnews.com

November 15, 2026

Religion & PowerConsciousnessBlack ChurchLeaving ChurchProdigal Original
Listen to the full episode

You were taught to look for God: up, out, somewhere past the ceiling of the sanctuary. On Prodigal: The Podcast Episode 49, Don Jackson and Daysha Voss ask the question underneath every religious debate: who is doing the searching? What "the world is an illusion" really means, concepts versus beliefs, "Before Abraham was, I am," the gold around the cross, Max Planck to today's analytic idealists, David Chalmers' hard problem and the 25-year bet neuroscience lost, the Black church as liberation and control with Howard Thurman and James Cone, and the hardest objections, answered on the air. Plus Daysha's extended meditation, "What Knows."

Listen: Prodigal: The Podcast, Episode 49, "Who Is Doing the Searching?"

You were taught to look for God.

Up. Out. Somewhere past the ceiling of the sanctuary. In a building, in a book, in a man with a robe and a microphone. You were taught what God is, what God wants, where God lives, and what you had to believe, say and do to get close. You were taught that God was the one thing in the universe you were farthest from.

I spent a good part of my life in that search. And there's one question nobody in that building ever asked me:

Who is doing the searching?

This is the ground we cover in Episode 49: the scriptures in context, the thinkers we lean on, and the objections we take seriously. You don't have to agree with any of it. The point is to look.

1. "The world is an illusion": what it means, and what it doesn't

The phrase gets thrown around as if it means your pain isn't real. It doesn't. The careful version is: the world as we conceive it is an illusion. Our thinking pictures a world of separate objects, separate people and separate stuff called matter. That picture is what's being questioned.

Your experience is not in question. Grief is real. Rent is real. Racism is real. Whatever you're experiencing right now, you cannot deny that you're experiencing it. What's open is the story about what experience is made of. Keep those two layers apart, and a lot of spiritual nonsense falls away, along with a lot of spiritual cruelty.

2. Concepts and beliefs

A concept is a tool: matter, money, a map, a name. You need concepts to build a bridge or buy a plane ticket.

A belief is a concept you've forgotten is a tool and started treating as the final truth about reality.

All beliefs are concepts. Not all concepts are beliefs. The problem is never owning a map. It's fighting people over whose map is the real river.

Not every strong conviction is dogma. If you believe the stove is hot because you touched it, that's evidence. Dogma is a belief you're forbidden to examine. The test is whether you're allowed to look.

Every church split is a map fight. Which name to baptize in, whether women can preach, whether you must speak in tongues, which day is the Sabbath, which translation is the real Bible. Good people who love God, divided for generations over the wording on the map, while nobody drinks from the river.

3. The scriptures, read in context first

If we're going to ask people to read past what they were taught, we have to read the actual text first.

John 8:58–59 (KJV). "Verily, verily, I say unto you, Before Abraham was, I am. Then took they up stones to cast at him." The crowd heard a claim to the divine name, and the traditional Christian reading, that Jesus is claiming to be God, has the text on its side. Many historians also note that John's "I am" sayings, which don't appear in Matthew, Mark or Luke, likely reflect how the early church understood Jesus. The contemplative reading notices the grammar: Jesus answers a question about the past in the present tense. "I am" points at something that doesn't live in time: not the body, but the simple fact of being aware. That reading is an interpretation, but it's an old one. Meister Eckhart, the 14th-century Christian mystic: "The eye through which I see God is the same eye through which God sees me." He was tried for heresy.

Exodus 3:14. "I AM THAT I AM" (Hebrew ehyeh asher ehyeh, also translated "I will be what I will be"). Its meaning is still debated.

Psalm 46:10. "Be still, and know that I am God." Read verse 9 first: "He maketh wars to cease unto the end of the earth." In context, the stillness is the nations laying down their weapons. The meditative reading is later and beautiful, but it is a reading.

Qur'an 2:115. "To God belong the east and the west; wherever you turn, there is the face of God." The Sufis took it literally.

4. The gold around the cross

In many medieval crucifixion paintings, the background is gold leaf. The painters didn't gild the bodies; they gilded everything around them. Art historians describe the gold ground as heavenly light, a realm outside ordinary time. The contemplative reading goes a step further: what's made to shine isn't the figures but the space they appear in. The body goes dark. The gold does not.

Across traditions, mystics describe the same shape:

  • Crucifixion: the death of what you thought you were.
  • Resurrection: the discovery of what you are underneath.
  • Transfiguration: life lit from within by that discovery.

Zen calls the first move "the great death" and the second "the great rebirth." These traditions are not the same, and we won't pretend they are. But something keeps getting noticed.

5. The Black church: liberation and control

The Black church was school, bank, organizing hall and shelter. It was often the only building in town Black people owned outright. The same pulpit that organized the boycott also told women to sit down. Liberation and control, under one roof.

Howard Thurman, Jesus and the Disinherited (1949): Jesus was a poor Jew under Roman occupation, one of those Thurman described as living with their backs against the wall, and what he offered them was an inner freedom no empire could reach. For Thurman, the inner life was fuel for the struggle, not an escape from it. Dr. King is said to have carried the book.

James H. Cone, The Cross and the Lynching Tree (2011): you cannot understand the cross in America without the lynching tree. The Equal Justice Initiative has documented more than 4,400 racial terror lynchings between 1877 and 1950. For Cone, the cross was a lynching: state violence against a colonized man. Our conclusion: any spiritual reading that lets you look away from the tree is a lie.

We hold both. The crucifixion's history is not negotiable. The contemplative reading has to make you more willing to stand at the foot of the tree, not less.

Leaving the building, not God. Pew Research found in 2024 that roughly one in five Black Americans is religiously unaffiliated, and most of them still believe: about a third in the God of the Bible, more than half in some other higher power. Nationally, Pew's 2025 Religious Landscape Study found 46% of the youngest adults identify as Christian, versus 80% of the oldest. Switching churches, leaving religion and deconstructing are different things. The only dishonest option is refusing to look.

6. The philosophers and the scientists

This is not a fringe idea. Some of the greatest minds in Western history landed here.

The philosophers

  • George Berkeley (1710): esse est percipi, to be is to be perceived.
  • Immanuel Kant: we never know things as they are in themselves, only as they appear to us through the structure of our own minds.
  • Arthur Schopenhauer (1818) opens his major work: "The world is my representation."
  • William James (1909) described a "mother-sea" of consciousness into which our individual minds plunge.

The physicists

  • Max Planck, father of quantum theory, to The Observer in 1931: "I regard consciousness as fundamental. I regard matter as derivative from consciousness. We cannot get behind consciousness. Everything that we talk about, everything that we regard as existing, postulates consciousness."
  • Arthur Eddington (1928): "The stuff of the world is mind-stuff."
  • Erwin Schrödinger: "Consciousness is a singular of which the plural is unknown."

Where things stand today

  • David Chalmers named "the hard problem of consciousness" in 1995. Science can map which brain activity accompanies which experience; no one has explained why any of it is felt.
  • The 25-year bet. In 1998, neuroscientist Christof Koch bet Chalmers a case of wine that a clear neural signature of consciousness would be found within 25 years. In June 2023, at the Association for the Scientific Study of Consciousness meeting in New York, Koch conceded and paid up. He re-bet for 2048; Chalmers took it.
  • Bernardo Kastrup, holder of doctorates in computer engineering and philosophy, is the leading voice of analytic idealism: one universal consciousness, with each of us like a whirlpool in a stream. The brain is what that local whirlpool looks like from outside.
  • Federico Faggin, who designed the Intel 4004 (the first commercial microprocessor), argues in Irreducible (2024) that consciousness is fundamental and cannot be built out of parts.
  • Donald Hoffman (The Case Against Reality, 2019): perception is a user interface, like desktop icons. It is useful for survival, but it doesn't show what's really there.
  • Contemporary teachers: Rupert Spira (The Nature of Consciousness), Francis Lucille, and Deepak Chopra (You Are the Universe, with physicist Menas Kafatos).

Our position: materialism has done extraordinary science, but as a complete explanation of experience, it's failing. Science hasn't proven consciousness is fundamental, and it hasn't proven it isn't. That is why the rest is introspection: look at your own experience honestly.

7. Where Prodigal stands, and the objections

We start from idealism: consciousness is primary, and matter is how consciousness appears. Source is not a person outside the universe; it's the reality everything arises in. A wave is fully real, and never separate from the ocean. A wave searching for the ocean is the self searching for God.

The objections we take on in the episode:

  • "The brain produces consciousness." The dependence of experience on the brain is real evidence. The open question is direction: does the brain produce consciousness, like a factory, or shape and limit it, like a radio shapes a broadcast? Damage the radio and the music changes. That doesn't mean the radio wrote the song.
  • "Real experience doesn't prove everything is consciousness." Agreed. Idealism is a philosophical position, not a proof.
  • "Then who's responsible?" At the level where we live, choices, harm and accountability are fully real.
  • "Why believe Prodigal instead of the church?" Don't believe us. Check it against your own experience. If it doesn't hold, throw it out.
  • "Where was Source on the lynching tree?" Evil is real, chosen and organized, and it must be resisted. If there is no ultimate "other," the man on the tree is not other than you. Oneness removes the last excuse for looking away.

8. Try this

Three times a day this week, when you catch yourself searching (for a feeling, an answer, approval, a sign), stop for one breath and ask: Who is doing the searching? Don't answer. Go back to your day. See what you notice by Sunday.

Notice the pattern. Interrupt it. We are Source.

— Don Jackson, Prodigal


Sources and reading: King James Version: John 8:58–59; Exodus 3:14; Psalm 46:9–10. Qur'an 2:115. Meister Eckhart, German sermons. Howard Thurman, Jesus and the Disinherited (1949). James H. Cone, The Cross and the Lynching Tree (2011). Equal Justice Initiative, Lynching in America. Pew Research Center, Black Americans who are religiously unaffiliated (Jan. 2024); Religious Landscape Study (Feb. 2025). George Berkeley, A Treatise Concerning the Principles of Human Knowledge (1710). Immanuel Kant, Critique of Pure Reason. Arthur Schopenhauer, The World as Will and Representation (1818). William James, "Confidences of a Psychical Researcher" (1909). Max Planck, interview, The Observer (Jan. 25, 1931). Arthur Eddington, The Nature of the Physical World (1928). Erwin Schrödinger, Mind and Matter (1958). David Chalmers, "Facing Up to the Problem of Consciousness" (1995). Scientific American and The New York Times on the Koch–Chalmers bet (June–July 2023). Bernardo Kastrup, The Idea of the World (2019). Federico Faggin, Irreducible (2024). Donald Hoffman, The Case Against Reality (2019). Rupert Spira, The Nature of Consciousness (2017). Deepak Chopra and Menas Kafatos, You Are the Universe (2017). Anil Seth, Being You (2021). Source and the ocean and the wave are Prodigal's own perspective, not settled science or settled theology.

Image: AI-generated background with a photograph of Don Jackson.

Ask Prodigal about this story

Got a question about what you just read? Ask, and get an answer drawn from this story.

5 free questions left today. Answers come only from this story and can be imperfect.

Want unlimited conversations? Try Prodigal AI

Share this story